User talk:FactChecker/Bury Pink Gril

About the move

I don't think we should move this page, i understand the ones about the video games and i do understand now but i don't see the bad in having an article about the mascot of the s4s board. https://soyjakwiki.net/Pink-Haired_Enbie exists and that is just as NAS as this.

it's brimstone my friend, no one cares about this shit — Brenton Harrison Tarrant (talk) 04:59, 9 September 2024 (EST)

I mean sure, it can be considered brimstone but it has been mentioned on the wiki a couple times i think and nevertheless is info that some readers might find useful. Keep in mind this wiki isn't just a circlejerk for you, and what you want. Some people just want to go through endless loops of constantly reading through new info, this can teach them something more about imageboard culture in general.

this wiki is just a circlejerk for ME

>this wiki is just a circlejerk for ME

Some key differences between Pink-Haired_Enbie and Bury_Pink_Gril

• Bury Pink Gril is almost never mentioned on the shardee

https://archive.marge.moe/search?query=bury+pink+grill (1 result) https://archive.marge.moe/search?query=bury+pink+gril (18 results, only 5 with a picture of pink gril) IIRC it was really only forced once, then disappeared completely. Nobody posts these anymore.

• Pink-Haired Enbie is mentioned on the sharty often. There are 4 pages of results on the 'chive

https://archive.marge.moe/search?query=Enbie

Furthermore, some of the memes made from Enbie were integrated into sharty lingo, such as "cute and valid" and has had far more of an impact and history with the sharty than Pink Gril, and therefore should have it's own page.

In short, Enbie is mentioned and posted far more often than this forced coal, and has had a considerable impact on shardee culture, whereas Pink Gril has had no discernable impact at all other than a booru janny trying to force it on the 'ki.

Just because it's posted on the sharty doesn't mean it needs an article here. There are several examples of other memes that are mentioned and posted on the sharty more often than these that don't have their own articles because they're completely unrelated to the sharty, such as Doge, Trollface, Shrek, etc. etc.

This should be moved back to User:FactChecker/Bury Pink Gril as User:Tefal, an admin, correctly did. ArticleFactChecker (talk) 13:39, 9 September 2024 (EST)

agreed or something — BrentonTarrant (talk) 13:52, 9 September 2024 (EST)

Also

>this can teach them something more about imageboard culture in general.

This is a Soyjak Wiki, not an imageboard wiki. ArticleFactChecker (talk) 14:00, 9 September 2024 (EST)

There are numerous soyjak edits of this, and it does get posted on the Sharty from time to time. I don't see a problem with having an article about it on here. Doge, Trollface, and Shrek don't currently have articles on here, but I don't see any reason why they shouldn't either, as all three are constantly posted on the Sharty and 'jakified.--MoonMetropolis (talk) 14:15, 9 September 2024 (EST)

• https://soyjakwiki.net/Soyjak_Wiki:Rules

>Pages should be at least tangentially related to soyjaks or soy culture.

ArticleFactChecker (talk) 15:08, 9 September 2024 (EST)

As I stated before, it is tangentially related to soy culture since it gets posted on the Sharty and gets 'jakified.--MoonMetropolis (talk) 16:28, 9 September 2024 (EST)

It's not related to soyjaks just because a few people posted it on the sharty.

This has several pages on SoyBooru: https://soybooru.com/post/list/bury_pink_gril/1

It absolutely should remain on the wiki.--MoonMetropolis (talk) 15:40, 10 September 2024 (EST)

It should absolutely be removed from the wiki. Being posted on the sharty or the booru does not make it related soyjaks or soy culture. This is a Soyjak Wiki, not a tranime wiki. ArticleFactChecker (talk) 15:52, 10 September 2024 (EST)